A Printable Reader's Guide to Stoner
The Wild Gentleman Book Club
This is the one-page reader's guide for The Wild Gentleman Book Club's in-person meetings. For the full guide, with background on the book and why it matters for men, see Stoner: A Reader's Guide.
Key Themes for Discussion
- Do What You Love - Once he gets the bug for literature and poetry, there is no other path for Stoner to take, and, with a bit of fortune, he ends up in a position to teach for the rest of his life. This passion is one of the few things he truly fights to hold onto.
- The Path You End Up On - School, career, marriage, family. This is the modern path, we are told, to happiness. Stoner follows this plan, for the most part, and the results are not a joyful existence. And yet, it is hard to argue that he did not live a good life.
- Principles - A lot that goes wrong in Stoner's life seems to result from his sound moral code. The outcomes of trying to do right make his life harder. And yet, a moment lacking "good morals" by societal standards stayed with me most: the love affair. That’s Stoner at his most natural.
- An American Odyssey - Stoner has adventures, but they differ from some of the classic American hero stories. But the journey is just as enthralling.
Questions to Explore

- One question in Archer Sloane’s class changes Stoner’s life. Did you ever have your own Sloane figure in your life?
- Stoner leaves the farm and a way of life that he seemed destined for. It is implied that his parents sacrificed a good deal to keep the farm operating and sent Stoner to college to support it in the future. Was his shift to literature a betrayal or actually a gift to them?
- Stoner never becomes the star professor, but he never stops loving the work and continuing to learn. In the end, was it enough for him? Would that be enough for you?
- Stoner does everything in what one might call the culturally prescribed order. Almost none of it goes as planned. Does that make the book more realistic? Do you have a moment in your own life path that defied the expected script?
- How do you perceive the character of Edith? Is she living a parallel mundane life to Stoner? Is she a villain, or is she trapped by the conventions of the day, similar to Stoner?
- What do you make of Stoner's relationship with Grace? How it started and how it changed. What about its final outcome? Should he have fought harder as a father at times, and why, do you think, he didn’t?
- A key moment, and one that will impact his career until its end, is Stoner's refusal to let Charles Walker get a pass on his oral exam. Was he right? Was it worth the retribution from Lomax?
- Stoner fights harder, more passionately, and more strategically for his teaching duties yet cedes control almost everywhere else in his life. Why teaching?
- The affair with Katherine Driscoll is a bit of a curveball, as it is the happiest we see Stoner. How do you square it with how it came to an end?
- If you put the character of Stoner next to Wendell Berry, Nick Offerman's storytelling, and fictional characters like John Grady Cole and Mattie Ross, does he mirror or connect with them in any way? Is this book an American adventure story?
Printable Reader's Guide:
Stoner: A Reader's Guide for The Wild Gentleman Book Club
